MovieChat Forums > Jonathan Demme Discussion > What was his best film?

What was his best film?


The Silence of the Lambs (1991) would be my pick.

reply

I'd agree with that pick. I think he's a bit underrated.

And many forget all the music stuff he did.

reply

I don't think he is a bit underrated. I think he's criminally underrated. I remember seeing Silence of the Lambs when it came out and thinking, "I have never seen a movie like this before in my life." Usually, you see a great movie and call it a day, but that was the first movie I ever saw when I knew I was seeing a game changing film. That movie was to the 90s what Psycho was to the 1960s, yet no one gives Demme or that film any credit. It's so weird.

reply

Besides Silence of the Lambs, I gotta go with Stop Making Sense. Anyone who's a Talking Heads fan needs to see this concert.

reply

not considered one of his major films by most, but i absolutely love something wild. it's like a movie that was programmed specifically to make me happy. it goes all over the place - fun, weird, violent, brutal at times, and unpredictable.

stop making sense would be #2. best concert film ever made to this day, i'd say.

reply

I'm a huge fan of Something Wild. Recommended it to someone a year and a half ago, a young lady named Audrey. Never did see her again but I hope she found it.

reply

Silence of the Lambs of course but other than that definitely Something Wild.

reply

I do feel that his best-known film (Lambs) is probably his finest hour, but I do like Melvin & Howard, Something Wild, Married to the Mob and Rachel Getting Married quite a lot, too. A talented filmmaker, gone too soon.

I haven't seen Stop Making Sense, Beloved or his pre-M&H films - I really should catch up.

reply

I don't think there's even a competition. Silence of the Lambs, because that movie was a completely game changer when it came out. Not only did it make a clean break from 1980s style cinema and scoring, it created so many horror and crime tropes that you can't imagine both genres being without.

reply