In Schindler's List is she???

This message has been deleted by the poster

i haven't seen it for years, but i don't think she is that girl. if you're talking about the girl in his bed before he goes on his balcony and shoots people thats not her. embeth plays the character who is picked to be the housemaid. when they are having the party she is the one downstairs by herself.

Actually she's the girl in bed with Ralph Fiennes, Embeth aka Hellen Hirsch
was Amon Goeth's Maid, and she shared his bed...
that was the whole point of making her his maid,
the thing is as a camp commander he could never have her as a lover in public, so he made her his maid and when nobody was watching he cared for her and she shared his bed,

so she was indeed the girl in amon's bed when he starts shooting people with his sniper rifle from the balcony

No, actually she wasn't the one in bed with Ralph Fiennes.
She was indeed his maid, but it was forbidden for him to sleep with her ( he as an aryan, and she a jew) and that's why he beats her so much-- out of sexual frustration. The girl in Ralph's bed was his mistress. It's clearly a different actress.


Support the ABFA
Come out of the garden, baby, you'll catch your death in the fog!

i haven't seen this movie in a long time - too depressing - but i'm remembering a scene when Ralph Fiennes beats one of his maids the one he picked specially, Embeth's char. i suppose? right?





"I'm a Buddhist - In case of accident, call a Lama" (The Ninth Configuration)

Yoda are we?

Embeth plays Helen Hirsch the maid Amon selects from a few female prisoners from his camp.
But I hardly recgonise her so I'm wondering if it's really her.
I have the DVD so I'll look it up...

no she is the one he liked but someone beat her up can't remember if she was killed