MovieChat Forums > Stanley Kubrick Discussion > The Aspergers/Autism Retrospective Diagn...

The Aspergers/Autism Retrospective Diagnoses


If you look at the wikipedia article 'Retrospective diagnoses of autism', you will find that Stanley Kubrick is on the list of people who possibly could've had an ASD diagnoses, but due to the time and the circumstances, had never recieved a diagnosis. As someone with Asperger Syndrome myself, I have very mixed feelings on this subject. The entry for Kubrick on the article is as follows:

Michael Fitzgerald and Viktoria Lyons see it as "convincing" stating that he was well known to have obsessive traits and found it socially difficult with his collaborators on set.

There are also many other articles and message boards you can easily find on Google relating to Stanley Kurick's possible Aspergers/ASD if you need more infomation. As I mentioned before, I have a diagnosis of Asperger Syndrome, and while I would love to see more creators on the ASD specrum, filmmakers or otherwise, i'm slightly uncomfortable with retrospectives of this kind, as I find the idea of debating the mental state of a real-life person somewhat disrespectful. It reminds me of papparazi stalking celebrities and creating theories around them, negative or not. I feel as though if a creator is on the ASD spectrum, it should only be celebrated and accepted if the person in question had comfirmed themself to have ASD/Aspergers, whether it's self diagnosed, or they have recieved a professional diagnosis. Whether you're autistic or not, i'd love to hear some thoughts on this.

reply

Troyal1, stop maliciously abusing the IMDB reporting function (a blind, dumb computer programme with a predictable set of instructions and responses regularly misused by internet trolls) to try and delete posts that differ with your thoughless, demented ravings. You are not 'autistic', but psychopathic (engaging in abusive behaviour in private while masquerading as a naïve idiot with 'autism" in public), as your behaviour in response to my posts proves ...

You are not a regular poster here, so if your aim is to stir up trouble (as is clear from your posts), you are treading on very dangerous ground.

"I was going to actually make a response until I saw this sentence."

LOL. You do realize the inconsistency/hypocrisy here? You were going to make a response until you decided not to as you decided to respond and did respond!!!!
LOL.

"Not be rude but that's flat out wrong and ignorant."

No. It is you who is chronically wrong and ignorant, pathetically so. What is wrong, obscene, delusional, are the crazed ravings of the originator of this thread. It's totally deranged - sociopathic- to slander someone, especially someone you clearly know nothing about, apart from being a famous filmmaker - as having "Asbergers/Autism", like calling a sociologist a 'sociopath', a psychologist a 'psychopath', or a psychotic a 'normal person'. Anyone who would make such an absurd claim is clearly a paranoid, delusional fantasist in need of some very basic social and psychological education/counselling ...

In clear and sparkling terms, go educate yourself on the basics of social reality, because you and the other poster strike me as someone who is chronically hermetic and anti-social, which is precisely why you are so obsessed with projecting delusional fantasies about "Asbergers/Autism" onto those without it, without even having the slightest clue about these 'clinical' pathological conditions.

reply

The thing is, Kubrick's qualities don't necessarily have to be accounted for by ASD, as they're not limited to it. Is it possible? To be fair, I wouldn't entirely discount it .. but I'm as wary as the OP about retrospectively diagnosing anyone with anything. I'm also wary about reducing an artist, or any human being for that matter, to a reductive label or symptom or syndrome of any kind, whether ASD or NT.

reply

I'd only say that "obsessive traits and found it socially difficult with his collaborators on set" is hardly limited to autism, and that a great many creative people of every neurological stripe show the same qualities in their work habits. An intense drive isn't strictly an autistic trait, it's a human trait.

reply

Why are so many messages "deleted by administrators"? Can adults have conversations without the kindergarten teachers waving tisk-tisk fingers in our faces?

reply