MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Have you ever "invented" something in yo...

Have you ever "invented" something in your mind that later became a real invention from someone else?


When I was 17 (1992) I had an idea for a new cartridge for the "1911" pistol platform. I wanted it to be .50 caliber, and I figured that if it were the ~same overall length as the .45 ACP cartridge, and used a "rebated rim" that was the ~same diameter as the .45 ACP's "rim," then it could work in a 1911 as-is, only needing a different barrel and magazine. I estimated that with a 300-grain bullet, you could get around 700 FPS without exceeding the relatively low pressure that you get with a standard 230-grain .45 ACP cartridge. I thought the ideal name for it would be ".50 ACP," though that couldn't happen unless Colt was onboard ("ACP" stands for "Automatic Colt Pistol").

I was working on the weekends at a laundromat at the time, and there was an older guy who always came in to do his laundry and talk guns. I told him about my idea and he argued that a .50 caliber cartridge could never fit in a 1911 as-is, i.e., he claimed that the frame and slide would need to be wider. I disagreed.

In the early 2000s when I first got a PC and internet access, I made a thread about my idea on the Guns & Ammo forum, and I encountered the exact same naysayer arguments as I got from the old guy in 1992.

Then in 2004 this came along...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.50_GI

... exactly as I "invented" it in my mind a dozen years prior (except for the "GI" name). Even the ballistics were exactly as I predicted (300 grain bullet @ 700 FPS), and it works in a standard size 1911 platform. It never became much of a success, but it did allow me to go back to that Guns & Ammo thread that I'd made a couple/few years earlier and say, "I told you so."

reply

Air tags
Metallic nail polish
eBay

- all stuff I wrote down in a spiral notebook in the ‘90s

reply

Metallic nail polish has been around for ages. It's the same idea as metallic paint like has been used for painting production cars since the late 1920s, and metallic ink which has been used in, e.g., screen printing for many decades. It's made by mixing metal powder or flakes with the paint or ink. I don't know when metallic nail polish was invented exactly, but I know that girls/women have been using it for as long as I can remember (I can remember as far back as the late 1970s).

reply

Not the substance, but the fashion trend. I remember trying to mix weird nail colors - blue, topaz, gun metal grey. Back then all the nail colors on the store shelves were shades of red and pink, except for cheapo ones sold for Halloween. Then a few years later Opi and other high end brands start selling good quality nail varnish in exotic colors. Missed the boat.

reply

are you a chemist?

reply

No

reply

Back in the early 2000s, I concocted this idea where mass transit, rather than running on a schedule with defined routes, would be based on demand and ride sharing. Users would plug in their destinations on a web browser (no smartphones then) and a “route” would be compiled for you along with others where you would share various legs on your journey, transferring between busses or taxis that would ultimately get you to where you wanted to go, hopefully very close to your doorstep. The routes would adjust based on where everyone needed to go.

While not a big deal in large cities, smaller metros don’t run many routes and usually just take you from city center to city center, never being a reasonable walking distance to your suburban home.

Should have just dumbed down the idea to be people running private taxis and calling it something silly like Uber.

reply