MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > A volcano erupts. There are four directo...

A volcano erupts. There are four directors. Three will die. You can only choose to save one.


Who do you choose? I'm voting PTA.

Quentin Tarantino
Christopher Nolan
Paul Thomas Anderson
David Fincher

reply

I'd run off, find David Lynch, and throw him in to form a lava plug and save everybody else.

reply

That's cold, man. What did Lynch do to you?

reply

1. Wasted 3 hours of my life watching his stinkbomb "Dune".
2. Wasted 30 hours of my life watching "Twin Peaks", waiting for a payoff that never came.
3. Wasted 1 hour of my life watching the first half of "Mulholland Dr." before I finally got smart and decided that I would not waste one more second of my life watching his pulled-out-of-his-ass crap.

You owe me 34 hours, Mr. Lynch. I don't know how you propose to compensate me, but I'm listening.

reply

Allow me to defend him.

1. He's not happy with Dune himself. The producers butchered the movie.

2. Are you including the latest season that came out recently?

3. I think Mulholland Dr. is a pretty awesome movie.

reply

2. No. Fool me twice, you know.

3. It's been several years since I tried to watch it, but it was when the guy (Robert Forster?) came out of the diner and saw the "boogeyman" in the parking lot that I thought, "OK, no more of this. This could have been a perfectly good thriller without made-up crap like this".

There's no doubt in my mind that Lynch laughs all the way to the bank while we talk about what his latest work "means". He probably says to himself, "Suckers! It doesn't mean a goddamn thing! It means my mortgage is paid off!"

reply

To be fair, I looked at the list of his works on imdb. I had no idea he directed "The Elephant Man". Even a blind hog finds an acorn now and then. I can only conclude Anthony Hopkins had the gravitas to make it clear that he wouldn't brook any bullshit.

reply

At least you saved 2 hours by staying away from Lost Highway, his worst movie.

reply

Can't I save someone who really matters???

reply

To me, everyone on that list matters except for Tarantino.

reply

Only Tarantino and Fincher have made movies I like and Tarantino's first 3 movies are among my all-time favourites.

On a personal level, Nolan and his family give me more creeps than the others, so he'd probably be the last one I'd save.

But what kind of dumb shit did these guys do that they need to be saved from a volcano??? Or did David Lynch tie them up or something?

reply

Q.T. & I WILL BE CHILLING IN THE CHOPPER,SMOKING A JOINT AND SCREAMING MOVIE LINES AT EACH OTHER.🙂

reply

No need to rub it in the faces of the deceased.

reply

Q.T. & I HAVE NO NEED FOR THOSE OLD DEAD WHITE GUYS.🙂

reply

Tarantino

reply

Because of him being friends with Harvey Weinstein and never telling on him for the bad things he did, I am leaving Quentin Tarrintino to die in the volcano.

reply

David Fincher

reply

David Fincher

reply

I'd save Paul Thomas Anderson, but I'm actually more intrigued to watch Tarantino's next movie because it's supposed to be the last one.

reply

I used to be a Tarantino fan, but he way his last few films are going, I don't even care anymore.

reply