MovieChat Forums > Politics > Science says you will always be a male

Science says you will always be a male


https://www.economist.com/the-economist-explains/2021/07/16/why-are-transgender-olympians-proving-so-controversial
The science suggests males retain an advantage over females, no matter how they identify

reply

Your title is bizarre. I have the impression you failed biology. All humans start off as female.

Actually, men are still half female XY. Women are XX.

Therefore, your title should read:
Science says you will always be at least partially female.

reply

Started but not finished. After finished you can't just think you can take the male genes away.Your body has structured itself in the male form god wanted it to be.

reply

I'll give you credit for knowing basic biology since you understand humans start as female. Replies from other posters demonstrate their complete ignorance of basic biology.

I'm not sure why trumplicans are so concerned with female sports when few watch them anyway.

reply

Because their children participate in them.

reply

It's not really accurate though, an androgen insensitive man doesn't have a penis, but he doesn't have a uterus either. If we actually started off as women, the AIS man would have a fully functional uterus and actually be a woman. Having the physical characteristics associated with women doesn't make you a woman. Fetuses aren't born female, they only lack primary sex characteristics until the influence of sex hormones begins their development later in gestation.

reply

the first letter is a place holder or X DNA, the second letter is the sex chromosome, dang KeKe, some failed 8th grade biology, haha

reply

Both X and Y are gender chromosomes.

"The “default” sex (i.e., without any other further input) is actually female."

You're playing semantics because you're in denial. You just called females a "placeholder". How insulting! LOL!

reply

Females are XX, males are XY. This isn’t hard you idiot. When having sex the female has to donate an X chromosome, if the male donates the Y then the child is male, if the male donates the X then the child is female. You can pretend that you’re another gender all you want, I’ll even call you by the right pronoun you want but you’re still the gender that your chromosomes say you are.

reply

Oh, oh! Someone is triggered.

This short film will explain how your lady parts turned into boy parts:
https://www.sciencealert.com/watch-we-were-once-all-female

reply

And yet your 23rd pair of chromosomes will still be XX.

You need to pick up a science book you stupid KKKeelai libtard.

reply

LOL! Now, you know why you have lady part nipples if you're a guy. You're welcome.

reply

The changes would have to happen on the cellular level you idiot. Cutting off certain body parts doesn’t change your cellular/genetic makeup. Party of science my ass lol

reply

Your lady parts must cause you distress!

reply

I don’t have lady parts numb nuts. Yes there are some parts that both men and women have but those aren’t lady parts, a lady part would be a vagina, clitoris, etc which I don’t have.

reply

Scary that you can't even identify correctly where your lady parts are on your body. I strongly suggest you watch the linked short film in my earlier post.

reply

Please explain to me what lady parts I have. I can’t wait to hear how you try to justify this nonsense

reply

https://www.sciencealert.com/watch-we-were-once-all-female

reply

Concession accepted

reply

Enjoy your nipples!

reply

Those aren’t lady parts numb nuts, just about every man on this planet has them yet are still biologically men (XY) nice try nimrod

reply

Don't you just hate it when you can't interchangeably swap your chromosomes on the fly? What if I want to pop a boob right now as a stress reliever? DAMN YOU NATURE!!

reply

"Actually, men are still half female XY."

Dear God, you are insane.

reply

What horrible public school did you attend to not know basic biology?

Catch up! It's written on a 5th grade level for you to understand:

"Sometimes the truth hurts, but nothing hits harder than a blow to your manhood: All guys start out, in utero, as females."
https://www.menshealth.com/health/a19516412/3-signs-you-started-as-a-girl/

reply

Men are not half female you idiot. If you have a Y chromosome you are defined as a 100% male. If you don’t have a Y chromosome you are defined as 100% female. It’s literally that simple you idiot, go pick up a science book.

reply

No one is 100%. That's why men have estrogen and women have testosterone.

Everyone starts off as female.

reply

Irrelevant, the scientific parameters of a male is they have one Y chromosome, females do not. You are scientifically illiterate

reply

You didn't argue my comment therefore you agree. Your ad hominem insult is your attempt to save face, I assume.

reply

[deleted]

It's hard to keep a straight face when posters have become triggered because they now realize they have lady parts.

reply

That’s because it was a non sequitur which I shouldn’t have to entertain, if I do then that gives you room to deflect away from what you know you can’t justify

reply

I notice you're afraid to watch a film which will help you identify your lady parts. LOL!

reply

Please explain what lady parts I have. Your entire premise is a contradiction as well because if I have them then they cease to be lady parts. Logic’s a bitch ain’t it

reply

Watch the film, wimpy guy w/lady parts.

reply

I see so you can’t explain. Concession accepted

reply

Enjoy your nipples!

reply

Those body parts are gender neutral

reply

I have the impression you failed biology.

Actually, men are still half female


Hahahahahaha!

reply

"men are still half female XY"

Actually, if this allows me to wander into the Swedish Bikini Team's locker room, I'm all for it.

reply

so what happened to your rant about Haley running for office in 2024 or where you at the capitol on the balcony waving a trump flag

reply

Hannah Barron,Alabama congress 2030
https://youtu.be/QDRjeNh26hI

reply

The women competing against him should refuse to participate.

reply

How dare you

reply

So I don’t like being 40 years old, if we go by libtard logic could I identify as a 27 year old? I’d really like to be 27 again.

reply

Congrats. Wow you look so old but you're actually so young in age. Opposite of Benjamin Button.

reply

Awesome, although now I’m kicking myself in the ass because when I was in high school I should have identified as a 21 year old so I could have bought beer.

reply

Ahh, yes. The old Ben Shapiro tactic who he only used once against a college kid.

But we all agree age isn't a social construct though, so it's a pointless argument.

The disagreement is that everyone who is male is additionally a boy who turns into a man, and everyone who is female is additionally a girl who turns into a woman. Male and female are biological types dictated by science (chromosomes), but boy, girl, man, woman are social constructs that mean whatever society dictates they mean.

Sex is biological like age. Gender is societal like a name. You can't change your age, but you can change your name. Saying a male can't be a woman is like me saying Shapiro can't use the nickname Ben because that name isn't on his birth certificate. It's Benjamin.

reply

It is a completely legitimate comparison. We have set scientific parameters as to what constitutes a male just like we have set scientific parameters as to what constitutes a 40 year old. If someone can change their gender just by saying so then I should be able to change my age just by saying so and you are an ageist for trying to deny me who I really am. Also Boy, girl, man and women refer to male and female you idiot which is dictated by their chromosomes, you are just making things up. If you are XY you are a male, you can still pretend you’re a female but you are a male. If I have lived 40 years I am a 40 year old but by your standard I should be able to pretend that I’m 27 and you should go along with it and accept it. You are saying I have to be a 40 year old because that’s what’s on the birth certificate yet you don’t apply that standard to sex, so which is it? Does the birth certificate matter or not? Because right now it seems like it does matter when it suits your argument but then it doesn’t when it suits your argument. I’ve noticed you do this quite often. If a persons genetic makeup is up for debate then so is the displacement of the fabric of space time and the 4th dimension

So which is it, little man: Am I a 27 year old or is a biological male a male end of story?

reply